HOMEMADE SMILES

Homemade ice cream made fresh daily in small batches

Serving Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavors Since 1975

Welcome to the Island Creamery website. We now have three ice cream shop locations. One on Chincoteague Island, Virginia, one in Berlin, Maryland and one in Salisbury, Maryland. Our family has been serving ice cream locally since 1975. We started making our own ice cream in 1985. Our creative ice cream flavors are a little different but very tasty. We find inspiration from local fruit farmers, our awesome team members and sometimes even our super loyal customers. We pride ourselves on producing the highest quality ice cream and ice cream cakes. All of our waffle cones are made fresh on premises with our secret recipe. Your experience at our ice cream stores is very important to us. We promise you’ll become an Island Creamery junkie with just one visit.

FLAVORS TO SUIT EVERYONE

People ask us every day, "How do you come up with such wonderful, original ice cream flavors?" We listen to our loyal customers and make the ice cream here. That's what makes owning the Island Creamery ice cream shop so much fun. We live in a great area for fresh produce and creativity. Our family strives to work with local farmers and like minded people to invent the most exciting ice cream concoctions. We make many of the inclusions in our kitchen as well as bake our own waffle cones daily.
LEARN MORE

TAKE SOME HOME

When our customers learn they can take our homemade ice cream home, their smiles get even brighter. Our ice cream is rich, creamy and made with some serious love. We will gladly pack a fresh pint or quart for your travels or late night cravings. Island Creamery ice cream makes the perfect gift for any type of celebration or holiday and many of our ice cream flavors are seasonal. You are certain to find something new each time you visit.
LEARN MORE

ICE CREAM CAKES

Island Creamery ice cream cakes are all made fresh in our kitchens. Who can resist a delicious cake layered with homemade ice cream and flavors like Oreo Delight, Chocolate Extreme, Peanut Butter Cup or traditional Chocolate and Vanilla? Call ahead to place a special order or drop by one of our three locations to pick up one from our ice cream cake freezer. For phone in orders, please be sure to specify the correct PICK UP location for your cake. (Note: our cakes do not include bread, they are solely ice cream)

LEARN MORE

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

Emily C
“There are so many amazing store made flavors to choose from! We had the marsh mud, java jolt, pony tracks, and peanut butter cup; and all were delicious, as were the brownies at the bottom. The whip cream is real!”
Emily C.
Washington, DC
K Sera S
Almost single-handedly (but not single scooped) responsible for a 5lb. weight gain in under 48 hours. ... I had the rocket fuel, double chocolate, regular chocolate, cake batter, vanilla butterscotch and cherry sorbet. 
K Sera S. 
Columbia, MD
Kathy R
I'm sitting here at 11:13pm on a Tuesday, on my balcony, overlooking the street below & the island creamery. I currently have a coconut & salted caramel combo from hand packed quarts we bought earlier.
Kathy R.
North Stonington, CT
HOLY GUACAMOLE, BAT MAN.... Actually I am surprised that is not a flavor. They not only have many different flavors they are all crazy delicious and handmade. It is not just the flavor it is the texture that really drives it home. 
Jim S.
Laurel, MD
Share by: